I really like the concept, and it fits the theme well, but I had a tough time playing since I really couldn't understand how it works. I'd have two sheep right next to each other, and one would die so I'd shoot the other, thinking that there's no possible way any other sheep could have killed one from across the pasture, only to be wrong every single time. It made it feel like the sheep were killed at random, or the imposter was random, which was frustrating as a player. Some other cues may have made it a little more forgiving to analyze.
Viewing post in Killer in Sheep's Clothing jam comments
Thanks for the feedback! :) Yeah you're right, there should have been more clues for the player. I was working on a playback feature to see how a run played out but it didn't make it into the game, which would help analyze what happened. I'll update the game post-jam when the rating period ends. We have a little hint that says the monster teleports away to safety after killing, but it's not very noticeable. We should also add that the monster does not kill while it's in the light. I'll update the description with some hints for now.
Thanks for playing, I hope you will get some enjoyment out of it with some updates :D