Fun: It's pretty hard to make an incremental game unfun, so it's fun, but lacks depth. The upgrades are pretty one note and the progression is all out of whack with the prices of buying more turtles not increasing as you get more of them. I liked seeing my pasture fill with more and more turtles. I didn't like hurting them, however. I also thought the decision to make the gun something you have to physically pick up more frustrating than anything.
Innovation: Doesn't innovate on the incremental genre much. But, I liked the combination of farming sim and incremental game.
Art: I found the models charming, but lacking in polish. The turtles move backwards for some reason
Sound: game has no audio at all
Theme: Fits the theme but doesn't do much to push the theme in any way.