itch.io

Thank you! I appreciate the longer review. I'm glad to evoke Heavy Metal; I love that movie. It's really a bit of an Appendix N reinterpretation itself, isn't it? I should have put a Locnar in the Treasure Vault, now that I think about it.

I really appreciate the constructive criticism. It can be hard to put honest, good-faith critique out there in Jams; we all care so deeply. I hope that if I respond to some things you've said here, you see it as engaging with your thoughts. If I seem defensive, forgive me! I'm a proud papa to this weird little module.

First, don't worry. Being familiar with Shadowdark lore wouldn't have made any of this nonsense more intuitive or familiar. What's a Chaos-Papess? My explanation is Here.

For the design, I should admit, I did not give Ryan much time at all to work his magic. My own incompetence came very close to making this whole thing a plain text document, and my Wednesday night game crew stepped in to save my bacon. Your point is well-taken, and I'm sure we could zhuzh the whole thing a bit, but I need to say that, if anything, my content does a disservice to the design, not the other way around.

Re: Random Encounter tables, I actually think Shadowdark needs them more than most similar OSR games. Because torches burn down using a real-world-time timer, there are less game-world-time constraints. Random Encounters become the thing that stops the party from feeling like they can pause, barricade the doors, and hunker down until they recharge. Without them, there's a disconnect between the game-time and real-time elements. In other words, Torch Timers keep the party moving; Random Encounters keep the characters moving.

Anyways, thank you again for the serious review. I hope you don't mind me responding! If you do get a chance to play the module, please let me know how it goes. If nothing else, enjoy Shadowdark! It's a fantastic little system.