Good day.
Unfortunately, there is no built in way to cause a total failure to give a specific item. The plugin does have the option to pass out failure items if a soft failure happens (as in, the recipe is correct, but it fails the random % check to craft it successfully), and also the global ability to show a failure item as if it were a successful craft, but there is no global ability to hand out a specific item on hard failure due to recipe incorrect. You can customize the total failure message to indicate that the whole recipe was a disaster, though.