A very unique and quirky idea. I like the concept, though it's quite confusing to know when each need is fulfilled because the chat bubbles appearing on each of the guys only sometimes went away after bringing the item and they seemed to get arbitrarily angry. It would also be great to have a label telling which level/night it is, because it was hard to tell if I was progressing or not. The dialog also could work better as chat bubbles, since there are 2 of similar looking characters that talk.
The song and general vibe of the game was really fun and I could see this going far. Good job.