Putting aside the terrible way they go about it (and your slop calls aren't helping you either), they have an absolutely valid point on the issues. You're trying to rail road people into the Loyal path, but want them to feel otherwise. This concept can work, absolutely, but what you've given is so restrictive. Tbc, these issues are exactly why I'm not giving this any further time. Frustration isn't usually a good result from playing a game.