This is awesome. First I tried to add BOX to my cake since I already had EGG, ICE and LEAVES and added three more ICE instead. Then I wanted to prepare a second cake since the oven took so long, burned my first cake in the process. Dropped the second one on the floor, picked it up again, tried to put it in the oven - it gets stuck on top of the oven. Finally finished the cake put some square icing and done. After that I made four more cakes at the same time to use the oven efficiently.
I love how jank the controls are, even if that's not the goal. The art and walking animation fit the jankiness perfectly. This might be one of the most fun games of this jam I have played so far. Sadly you will probably improve the controls since the others don't seem to appreciate the jank like I do, but I would love it if you could make a copy of this version still available after you improve it.
(please note that all of this is meant seriously and positively in case it comes of as sarcastic or mocking, I truly actually like it)
Edit: after this I couldn't stop myself from making four more cakes.