Hello! Here on the left are the settings I used for importing them into Unity, for pixel clarity. 
For alignment, I found that both fonts should have the same X position, but the outline should be placed 1px higher on Y axis. So, if "FantasyRPGtitle" Pos Y is 4, then "FantasyRPGtitleOutline" should be at 5. This way they align perfectly. Not sure why this is needed, since I created them in the same size and grid...
I hope this solves the issue for you!