Enjoyment: there were multiple paths to chose from, even if they just went full circle it tempted me to explore.
Gameplay: I sadly got lost and couldnt finish it. I watered the tree once and then I had no idea what to do. When talking to the tree I could not really make the dialogbox go away, only ESC and M helped which felt weird.
Innovation: I assume there are multiple items to solve puzzles which makes it a nice approach to the genre.
Theme: Excellent setting, the forest felt surreal and strange. An alarming feeling kept my company while playing
Audio: Strongest category for your game. Really well done, atmospheric and thrilling, kinda happy there were no jump scares in what I have found, would have really gotten me. Really good job!