Playability:
Feels like a puzzle game in which you judge the dead. There doesn't seem to be any stakes or objective beyond matching reapers to souls. No visual benefit or loss based on outcome seems to occur. Would like to see more meaning to actions across the board.
Theme:
Fits the theme well in that you are watching everyone who dies in the world and judging them based on the feelings and interests of a given reaper. Interesting and unique take.
Cleverness:
Great writing throughout with a lot of mini-stories available for each of the souls and reapers. Really well put together and compelling.
Artistic Style:
Incredible pixel art and a great soundtrack to go with it. Fantastic work.