Oh there are probably lots in Itchio! I mean if you are looking for something which has similar short point-and-click cooking vibe it might be bit harder but looking with tags definitely helps. If you're looking for something which has similar vibe of mysterious figure vaguely threatening you, something like a dark twist on a dating sim, you will find lots of them just by going to the front page of Itchio, lots of great ones out there! ^^
Sorry I don't have any specific recommendations, I based this game on the old cocktail bartender web game with a cocoa twist as that's my personal choice of drink. But good luck out there~