Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+1)

I think I'm missing something. I don't see the target DC to navigate. In the example, it says 18, but in tile 5 (the only other place I saw that listed one)  it says 15 and it's unclear if the GM how to make this determination. Also it feels weird that the smarter you are, the more likely you are to wrap over. Seems like that's counter-intuitive to the purpose. DCs are all over the place as well with very few using the standard DCs. It makes it harder to determine what I should be doing with the navigation since there's not a consistent target number. 

There's no static Navigation DC as that would vary by environment and conditions (rain, dark, fatigue, rapids, etc.)

Just like the power meter, there's a risk of hitting the ball too hard — a high STR doesn't make you good golfer.

A high INT could be overthinking, analysis paralysis, overconfidence, etc.

(+1)

I think it would help to explain there's no set Navigation DC and that the GM should use some best practices for how to make that determination.

I can add that later, but it's stated plainly in the RAW under "Navigation" on page 90 based on terrain familiarity which would vary. And, like all checks, "the GM chooses...a number called a difficulty class (DC) (p.9). I was careful to change only the roll; nothing else.

You should reference the rules you are using when you change them. Especially when there are 2 sets of overland travel rules. One in the core book & one in the new material from the Western Reaches. The navigation rules do not set a DC which is why they are being expanded upon in Western Reaches, because it's unclear how it works in the core book. It doesn't account for the weather, familiarity, nothing. The DC check for it would be based on the standard 9, 12, 15, 18, 20. These checks are based on a natural 1d20 roll. You modified the roll, but not the DC after describing it as an "inscrutable labyrinth" that "proves... difficult." The question I'm raising is how difficult is it? Is it Easy on a sunny day? Is it Hard? How does the rain affect it? Does this change with the new rules? A little clarity would go a long way to making it more usable. If there had been standard DCs elsewhere, it would have been easier to determine what you think the environment difficulty for your adventure was.