Playability:
Simple to play and understand. Only works with controller so keep that in mind. Aiming is a bit slow but that can be improved.
Theme:
Not feeling the theme heavily as it's more a storyline backdrop setting for the game. Would have loved to see it tie into gameplay in some way.
Cleverness:
Super interesting to see a dodgeball game. Not something that is very common. Nice work on this and definitely keep developing it!
Artistic Style:
Mostly consistent and I can see the direction you're trying to go. Consistency in graphic design is the most important aspect so focus on that!