Connection to Theme: 4/5. Not the simplest times but fits the theme.
Enjoyment: 2/5. The controls are very unresponsive and it was hard to tell what I'm looking at.
Presentation: 2/5. Fully ASCII art games are hard to ignore, but it makes the player try and decipher what's happening on screen. Also the complete abscence of sounds is a thing here.
Gameplay: 2/5. Again, the controls are very unresponsive. You can't really dodge enemies' bullets and can't collect the "!" on time.
Creativity: 4/5. Mostly for the ASCII art, but also a sailing game is an interesting concept.