Connection to Theme: 4/5. It does show an interesting time period but not really a simpler one.
Enjoyment: 4/5. Started to get a bit tired of it around day 30.
Presentation: 5/5. The style is simple but comprenehsive and visually appealing. The music is simple but I don't get tired of it quickly.
Gameplay: 3/5. Really wish there were more things to do other than the Y/N choices, waiting for expeditions, using bandages and occasionally clicking animals. The game is too easy with 2 people but quickly gets impossible if you recruit more as they'll evaporate half your food each day.
Creativity: 3/5. Overall, it's a pretty simple choice game and I haven't seen any totally unique things in it.