Ngl i have many theories why the inconsistencies happen to show up, but one in-universe reason is that this is all a play. These horny ass witches and elfs decided to role-play pretending that men don't exist by kicking every single guy out or person that is in the way of disrupting their fantasies, thus they have the town for themselves and get to BOINK arthur
But hey... that does not sound cool so keep making stuff up :3