I'm gonna be serious- the moment I saw the moustache on the sheriff I thought this was gonna be a funny animation, but then it took a gritty turn!
The time limit on this jam was pretty short, and I think your cutscene could use a bit more polish. For example- the phone keeps ringing after the sheriff picks it up and in the scene with the car the music from the previous scene still plays. Then again- I always appreciate voice acting in a jam submission, so that was cool,
The graphics reminded me of the flash animations from the early 2000s, so they tickled me just the right way ;)
As for the cinematography- the camera setup was simple, but this made it very readable. Every scene was clear. The last take (with the camera shake) was really cool, and it sold the sheriff's grief and rage.
Your take on the theme was a sad and gritty one. I liked it. If you spin this into a bigger game, I'd gladly play it :)