5 is the standard penalty for most villagers and outcasts. That’s almost all the characters.
2 when killing a drunk because the drunk acts like an evil and sometimes you can’t avoid spiking him trying to figure out who is actually evil.
9 for a corrupted knight
6 for a drunk disguised as a knight (special case)
∞ for a real bombardier
And Lilis subtracts 2 health every fourth flip which is why Lilis rounds can look a little weird healthwise.