The pink one who we know to be Columbina actually has three accounts of her death atm. Harlequin’s puppet show, jester’s play and Ticket taker’s mirror. We are told that each one made their own account of the event to protect themselves from the trauma of what happened. This means that each account leaves out the parts that the story teller can’t/won’t accept. For example, Harlequin doesn’t mention the romance and tries to play off her death as a willing sacrifice which we know to be a lie. While Jester focuses solely on the love triangle and completely leaves out the part of her being eaten and the situation that influenced that tragic outcome other than the love triangle.
The mirror version is portrayed as being Columbina’s own retelling of the event but interestingly it’s the Ticket taker who encouraged us to look into that particular mirror. The mirror is the one I believe to be the most accurate version. I think only by repeatedly viewing these stories and comparing them can we get an idea of what really was going on.
I love discussing theories on this game though. There’s just so much to unpack