hi everyone.

just saw the notification for the chapter 3 announcement, which reminded me of something.

during my first ever playthrough, i was able to get a specific scene: 
MC was currently on the ship to the new city. then they take out the "chalice" (its been a while, so i dont remember exactly what, but it was the item we were tasked to find), think about what to do with it, before thowing it into the ocean.

i really liked this scene, but on following playthroughs i was never be able to get this scene again.
so i wanted to ask how/which choices i have to make to get this scene? or did i imagine this scene and it doesnt exist?

thank you for oyur help.