I didn't think epic music matched the tone and it kind of jumps at you. It seemed a bit heavy for a confessional. Though the piano song at the end was pleasant. When played out of the browser I couldn't view the dialogue options and when in full screen some options covered the center text.
The eye personally gave me a good chuckle. To be in the confessional box and the Priest say "I know what you are!" hah. Through story-wise it is interesting to see how someone could be earnest vs. not putting in effort.
The five year jumps and the beard growing was a nice artistic touch but I wonder if you could show dark hair turning white. Obviously we only had 72 hours to complete this and the artwork was cool.