the bad end from the 2nd choice is one of the most absurd thing I've seen in a VN
this whole thing (between non celebrities) wouldn't even make a footnote in local news, and while it would affect your relationships with people who find out (some people would avoid you while others might even get close to you because of it, be it curiosity or some other reason), your boss might put you into a lower position at your job to avoid potential scrutiny but I highly I doubt you'd lose it, them being basically nobodies and forced into hiding and having their lives irreparably scarred over it...
it's so absurd it could have been funny if the way it was told wasn't so overly serious, but because it's a dreary depressing bad end with ominous and sad music it's just really really weird, really weird