The Puppet is the only evil character who tells the truth, and it specifically says so in the description. Many characters who corrupt specifically corrupt only villagers, and the Plague Doctor is an outcast, not a villager. No vague mechanics.
the comment above is right. the wretch is next to the chancellor, and everyone sees the wretch as evil, including the evils themselves lol from the baa's perspective, there are two evils (the wretch and chancellor) sitting next to each other
