That's how it goes, you can't do anything "right" in the early stages in her eyes. Just make the choices you think are best, the rest will come quite some later. Lucy is a slow progress character
The easiest way is to always pick the top option in choices, this way you will get the best outcome with her :)
You can also skip everything when you start over, just hold ctrl or tap the "skip" button under the textbox, then it takes you just a few minutes till you are back at chapter 3
