I think the new controls just have some kinks to work out, and they'll be fantastic.
Keep in mind this is a test version, so most likely they'll improve upon the controls with future updates. And speaking of future updates...
I also think you can see the intention for some future updates in the new controls. Take the microwave, for example: With the new controls I think it would be better if the microwave had physical dials and buttons on the front that you can push to adjust the timer and start the cycle. Kinda like how you turn dials and push buttons on the download console.
I wonder if these new controls hint at the idea of making interactions more physically based, instead of scrolling through menu lists. Which would certainly be more immersive. And fun. Who doesn't love pushing buttons and twisting dials and pulling levers?