I've run this game twice now, and each time it's been a stand-out role-playing experience. It appears to be a crowd-pleaser. This game does exactly what it sets out to do, and it's mesmerizing - like a magic trick.
The 1st time, we ran the February track, and the game was dark, haunting, and surreal. It was fun and exciting, but it had an emotional kick that's not common in rpgs. It was not goofy or silly.
This time, we ran the October track, and the game was a silly, light-hearted ghosts-and-goblins romp, complete with witches dancing around a bonfire, bubbling cauldrons, and so forth. It was a picture-perfect Halloween game, and we all had a great time.