Absolutely loved the concept for this one! Social deduction games are always really fun to play, and I took notes all throughout the game, trying to work out which lines were relevant and which weren't. I like that each creature had a few lines of lore about them, and that there were more creatures types than there were characters.
Unfortunately where I did feel things fell apart a bit was in the actual deductions - the clues for each character felt quite vague, and the one character whose species I was able to identify was mostly a guess based on some evidence found early on. It would have been nice if giving the "right" gift to a character gave you a much bigger clue as to who they were, or at least let you more definitively narrow it down to two or three choices.
The pixel art looked fantastic, and the implied backstories of all of the characters did a good job of hinting at interesting pasts. I'd definitely like to see this expanded more, and to have things fleshed out a bit. Good job!