I think a few other people have commented on the general sound of the instruments and production and how that could be improved so I'll just focus on the stuff I liked...which was a lot!
I will say that the simplistic feel of the instruments themselves and the production does actually give it a slight PSOne sample-based JRPG soundtrack feel to me, which I really enjoy. There were definitely some moments in track 1 where I could feel that energy and excitement coming through, almost like battle music.
Track 2 has more of a lengthy build to it and there's a lot to like about your composition style. Also really liked the background sound design on this one too.
Really nice work, especially considering you have not done this before. I feel like you've got an ear for it so would love to hear more as you keep honing your style!