Post by Niven Hedinger in Weekend Renters comments

Viewing post in Weekend Renters comments

"I can't understand who criticizes the ending" - sorry, but did you play the game? It starts with an old man dying in his house. They claim it was an accident and no one even bothers to investigate what really happened? They don't check the house, nothing and the main character inherits the house without any information about the basement below - even for a short horror game, it's just a logic flaw, big one. This developer has made great games and making a story mistake like this doesn't look good.

Furthermore, if you actually play the game, in the end the character says that several renters have disappeared. Where did they go? You expect me to believe nobody even asked questions about it? In the game there is a literal poster ad for the cabin and it is made by the protagonist's SON and HE DID NOT EVEN BOTHER QUESTION WHERE IS MY PARENT.

Edit: The game is good, but ending is a mess, sorry that's factual and you can't objectively prove me wrong. If you like the game, that's good to hear, but don't just say that you don't understand people, who didn't like the game, sounds a bit snobby.

AtmoPixel80 days ago

please add a spoiler warning, thanks for the feedback guys :)

Niven Hedinger80 days ago

With all due respect, this is a public page, the last time I checked. There are tons of videos filled with spoiler thumbnails and comments, so my question to you is why single me out? Maybe because you don't like my comments, which is sad, because I would expect someone with tons of experience and great games to understand what criticism is, not to mention I supported most of your projects.

Alright I guess.

AtmoPixel80 days ago

your comment has so many spoilers (compared to other ones) that I honestly lost count. I absolutely accept your criticism. Its important to take feedback seriously to improve my games. I appreciate that you enjoyed my previous work and hopefully you will enjoy my next one as well. And btw just like you dont understand how someone could like the story, others dont understand how someone could dislike it. You cant be mad about it, opinions work like that.

Niven Hedinger80 days ago

First of, the times of me following your work are long gone now, not to mention support and recommendations of your work. Second, my comment has as much spoilers as any video posted on a PUBLIC page, so maybe you can change couple of settings if you can't handle it directly. Third - maybe you should re-read my comment, although I doubt you will - I never said anything about people liking the game. The person I replied too said that they don't understand how someone can criticize the ending. Please, at least pay attention to what people write. I never said or got mad about people liking your work, because it doesn't make sense, I made a video on it.

Good luck anyways.

AtmoPixel80 days ago

You think Im salty about your comments but no, thanks for the feedback I read it multiple times. All I asked for was a spoiler warning. videos in comment section doesnt have autoplay so no spoilers are revealed meanwhile your comment is the longest comment I ever got with so many spoilers I can't even count them.

Niven Hedinger80 days ago

Again, definitely salty and upset that not everyone praises your work, specifically pointing out major plot holes and inconsistency with the ending, which you will never address. As for the spoilers, where do you think the game is posted? Do you own the site? Do you censor public opinion and free speech? Asking for something doesn't necessarily give you the right to own anything or anyone, so, in real life our conversation would go very differently. Comments aren't on autoplay either, people can just not read my comment. You make less and less sense and I urge you to stop. Not going to support your work or write anything else, leave this be.

AtmoPixel80 days ago

why are you so mad? yes I own this game site <3 I appreciate your feedback thats why im not removing your spoiler comment. you missed some things in the story and youre overthinking certain parts but its ok I respect your opinion and it was definitely good feedback for me to improve my games in the future. Im not salty or mad at all and its sad it had to turn into this. Good luck with your future projects and your yt channel.

Niven Hedinger80 days ago

You don't own this website, again, you either can't read or understand English. You can do whatever you want, that's what I am trying to explain to you - this is a public forum! I can write whatever I want as long as I am following the guidelines written by the official website owners, NOT YOU. I didn't miss anything in the story, stop making excuses for the poorly executed ending. You can't objectively prove anything. The only thing I am mad at is wasting time, money and effort for someone, who doesn't know their audience and only cares about none commentary YouTubers just showcasing their games without giving a second thought.

AtmoPixel80 days ago

what made you think i only care about noncommentary vids? I just watched a big streamers gameplay and he and his chat liked the game and the plot twist at the end. Im glad they enjoyed. I dont own this website but I own this game site and I can apply my rules here if i want. I still like how I did the ending and im very happy to see people are liking it too.

View more in thread

itch.io

Viewing post in Weekend Renters comments