...Gosh dang it. I put a barrier that was supposed to turn the boat around if you sailed out too far. I also thought I prevented using anything on the boat till you looked at the scary thing... Oh well, thanks for letting me know.
Update: Fixed the barrier. However, I have no idea how you broke the jump scare. It's supposed to disable your ability to click anything on the boat when you get the fish, which would be at a time when you still can't click anything.