This is probably my favorite one so far. So silly and funny - you guys NAILED the theme (sailing on a gravy boat for example). I like the random choices and stat rolls - Only 2 runs, but I had fairly different encounters enough to be memorable. Do some outcomes just lead to death? Or is it a certain number of failed checks?
The music and art is great and really work together to set the ambiance. Favorite moments are dying to the voices in the storm, and the Biscuit Brigade absolutely destroying the cabin boy, just murked him.
Only feedback is it would be nice to see your crew stats before you decide on a choice.