Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+1)

The idea shows promise. Here's some feedback on the prototype (coming from someone who enjoys games like Civ), mostly regarding the UI and UX:


- A lot of the UI interactions had me click on small toggles and buttons. For example, when I had to select a manager I had to click on a small toggle option; I would like to just click anywhere on the messenger's UI element to select them. Try to remove unnecessary empty space and make the interactive buttons larger.
- I should be able to click-and-drag to pan the map, and the scroll-wheel should be able to zoom in and out. 
- I didn't like how a window appeared in the middle of the screen when clicking on tiles, the tax centre, etc. It blocked the center view and prevented me from clicking on other tiles. It was made worse by not being able to close the window by clicking outside of it; I had to click the small "Close Window" button at the top. I think having a semi-permanent "interaction panel" in the corner or on the sidebar (like Civilization) that updates its content when I click on something would work better here.
- Definitely add more user feedback in response to actions. The biggest one is the messengers; I would like to pull up a list of messengers and see their status at a glance (i.e. check their availability, view their stats). I would also like some kind of notification when a messenger returns. Instant feedback should also be there when clicking on actions like "Establish Settlement".

I know that's a long write-up, but I think these changes will go a long way to make the prototype feel more responsive and fun. The core idea of sending messengers to enact your strategies sounds like it could be really fun once it's more fleshed out, so I'm looking forward to see what you can do with this!

Fantastic feedback, greatly appreciate it and I can agree to all you've listed! We actually sat down today before submitting and planned out some UI/UX improvements over the next couple of days. it's hilarious because we even chose Civ5 to examine and decided to go with the hover-over-tile to view basic stats and then a sidebar for actions :D The feedback response on messengers will be interesting to decide on as we want to keep a certain amount of uncertainty but with the balance of the player being sure of what is happening action-wise. Again thank you for the extensive feedback and for checking the prototype out :D