Downloaded the windows version and played it, absolutely love the style and concept! The mechanics for actually keeping the fish on the line feels too "floaty" (as in I couldn't even tell at some points if my input was actually registering) to feel like the fish catches past the early ones are earned, let alone the hard ones actually being catchable (at least to me lol). But absolutely cool concept!
Viewing post in Moonlit Fishing (Scream Forever Jam) jam comments
That was 100% intentional but totally fair that it doesn't 'feel' good (you have to hold down the direction), the hit box was more visible but I made it more subtle to not be distracting so I see that was actually a mistake because it sounds like you couldn't see it. All of the fish are too easy for me but a play tester could never catch the hardest one so you're not alone, if you cast out far you will always encounter a 'difficult' catch so you were actually just casting out further and further naturally making the game more difficult lol.