I'm gonna rate this like I'm right and everyone else is insane, even though I might be insane and everyone else is probably right but...
The stuff that happens with Lugh, that isn't real right? I mean I've played enough videogames to know that Lugh is the name of a member of the Tuatha Dé Danann, and I think he represents light and craftmanship? Idk though my knowledge of that kind of stuff is shaky at best, I just know that he's Cu Chulainn's dad. Anyway! Between the title being "It Could Be," the tropey (as even pointed out by Lugh) meeting of Dusty and Lugh, Dusty's love for romance novels, and his frequenting of the park wishing fountain, along with that being the final scene, and perhaps most importantly that the choices you make influence how things go with lugh... but don't really change how things go with Randall at all. The fantasy with Lugh is lit in this pink ethereal dreamlike light, and everything with Randall is grounded in real color. If that's the intent? Peak cinema. That's the read I got, but I see other people's comments everyone thinks it's just a standard love story told out of chronological order, in which case neat, but I feel like you could've done a little bit more with that then. Compare and Contrast Lugh and Randall even more. Tell us how Dusty got out of the south. etc. I get it, it's a Jam, limited words, limited time. I really liked the whole presentation, the light in a dark was a little weak, but on the other hand "Cock in the butthole, Lugh!" is a really charming scene so you still get 5s across the board.
Seriously though please let me know if I'm right or not I feel like I'm going insane.