Wait, if you've done the part where you saved Jasmine from being sacrificed, you shouldn't have to talk to Alice anymore.
You only talk to Alice when you're trying to find out how to save Jasmine.
After Jasmine has been saved, you'll take her back home, then have a bath scene with her.
Then the next day you go to the living room during the night and there's another scene with Lily sitting on the hill together.
There shouldn't be a quest to talk to Alice anymore for Jasmine's story after that. You'll need to focus on Violet and the other girls.