Story - Cute little story that fit with the theme, the world, and the gameplay nicely! Really brilliant idea with the asynchronous multiplayer, as it felt like a living world even though I didn't see anyone else around.
Mechanics - Solid mechanics all around! Really impressed that you guys managed to create a full on upgrade tree! Really great work. I'm a sucker for a good roguelite and this game really hit the spot.
Theme - I think you guys really nailed the theme here. Correct me if I'm wrong, but creating a connection takes away some of your own resources, right? If so, then that really hits the notes of generosity beautifully.
Audio/Visual - Fantastic music, sound effects, and little characters! Really a treat all around.
Overall - Super fun game with some solid gameplay and a touching multiplayer mechanic that made the game feel personal in an impersonal way (if that makes any sense lol). Awesome job!