Feedback
Last week I posted on the weekly Feedback Friday thread over on the gamedev subreddit. Feedback is essential for moving my game foward! Taking on criticism is often difficult but taking it on board is a skill I'm refining and getting much better at. Because of this I welcome any and all feedback I get – the rough and the smooth.
I got a fair few comments last week and managed to extract a good amount of criticism to work with:
- Destructible rocks were good apparently.
- Good feedback on the music by Spiff Tune.
- Too much text in the tutorial.
- The mimic spawning on the first chest gave a player a bad time.
- Someone liked the colour options.
- One person died on the first stage.
- Tutorial was bad. Someone didn't know what Shards and such were.
- The game feels somewhat polished.
- One person stopped at stage 8 before getting bored and quitting.
- Looks awful on high definition screens and resolutions.
Thoughts on the Feedback
Lets have a look at some things that stood out to me and how I can fix them!
- Looks awful on high definition screens and resolutions.
A few users were kind enough to supply screenshots from their devices. This was great! I got to see how truly terrible it looks.
This is a difficult one for me to address because I don't have a high definition monitor or any new Android devices. So I can't rapidly view changes on the fly to make sure things look OK. Regardless, I need to fix this! It's going to put a lot of testers off.
I plan to update the assets to scale with the screen's width. I'll have LOW, MEDIUM and HIGH user interface assets. I'll try updating the fonts, dialogue windows and buttons to scale better.
- Tutorial was bad. Someone didn't know what Shards and such were
- Too much text in the tutorial.
Another valid criticism. The previous tutorial was tacked on and overly wordy. I'm going to try a "less is more" approach here and add contextual tool-tips. I don't want the player to be sitting and reading for ages before they can do something.
- One person stopped at stage 8 before getting bored and quitting.
Pacing is something I've been trying to get right and if someone wasn't engaged at stage 8 I feel I've don't something wrong here and the pace is too slow. Currently, the format is something like this:
- Stage 1 – 3 total enemies, 2 new enemy types
- Stage 2 – 3 total enemies, 1 new enemy type
- Stage 3 – 3 total enemies, 1 new enemy type
- Stage 4 – 4 random enemies from before
- Stage 5 – Boss
To increase the pace and keep things fresh I'm changing this to:
- Stage 1 – 3 total enemies, 2 new enemy types
- Stage 2 – 3 total enemies, 1 new enemy type
- Stage 3 – 4 random enemies, 1 new enemy type
- Stage 4 – Boss
This means bosses will come around quicker and a new enemy type is shown every stage. It does mean I'll eventually have to create more unique enemies to hit my 50 Stage goal for release but that's not so bad. We'll see how this does!
- The Mimic spawning on the first chest gave a player a bad time.
This was an interesting one! The player in question self admitted not liking these sorts of tactics games and when he got ambushed by the Mimic enemy from the first chest he looted, I feel this was his last straw and he was scared to pick up any other chests. Admittedly it's not very new-user friendly for that situation to happen. I made a sneaky change to only allow Mimics to spawn after 2 chests had been successfully looted to avoid making new players think chests were bad things.
The Mimic Causing Havoc
Conclusion
I've got a lot of changes to make for the next feedback session! I'm hoping I can at least get the resolution changes up and running for this Friday and the rest for the Friday after.
If you'd like to try the Android version, you can here and you can download the desktop version through my itch.io page.
If you have any feedback let me know!