So I was right the first time. That being said I was worried that making the players drag a wet dead body out of the pool would be a bit of a turnoff. So I decided to cut that part out.
Make it a deflated sex doll instead. Moderately less distressing, depending on who it's of, but still damned humiliating
Ooooohhh... wish I thought of that!
could even lead to a humorously frustrating event where it springs a leak and flys off a few tiles away.