Why do VN artists keep doing this to us? Are we not allowed to have any twinks? Thick arms, pecks the size of his head... Who is this? What did you do to my boy? Why?

Where were you when Monchimutt joined the twink genocide?
> he was unrealistically twinky for someone of his background
Debatable. But regardless, it's a porn FVN about magic and ancient ghostly Viziers, this is not and has never been about realism. Please don't try to make this about something irrelevant.
What this IS about is Monchimutt pulling a bait and switch, betraying the trust of his community by changing a character's design in a meaningful way without a discussion. This is a huge middle finger to each and every one of us, including you. This is a message, and it says: "I do what I want and I do not care about your opinions and emotional investments in the slightest".
> John is clearly the embodiment of Twinkness still
John in his next update if we don't rise up against Monchi's tyranny:

As I am free to give them shit for it.
If the game suddenly turned into a body horror with straight romance - you wouldn't be defending the developer, you would be up in arms, because the game would be ruined for you. I'm exaggerating to make my point obvious, of course, but it doesn't really matter how far off from your expectation the game goes, when it's already out of bounds of acceptable for you.
The original designs were a promise. To change that - is to betray the trust of the community. This is why a good developer includes the community in the decision-making process when it's something that can make or break the entire project for large portions of the fanbase.
Monchi didn't do it, which mean he doesn't respect us. We didn't even get a heads-up, it was just dropped on us - in his eyes we don't even deserve a fucking word of warning from his fucking majesty.
So it's really bizarre that all these people with a para-social relationship with a person who doesn't give a shit about them are defending him.