I prefer the new one.
The old one looked like a boy... It was weird.
The skin was also red? Now it is pink. Eye color changed too.
It feels more inline with the cow design too.
Definitely disagree with the “looked like a boy”. With the colour I felt it was more in line with the rest of the game, in the dark pig sty and whatnot, so that’s actually one of the things I preferred. New Swinky stands out more in a way that doesn’t seem to fit quite as well with the rest of the art
I can see the argument of her new face being a bit more in line with Nancy’s design, though I liked that they were different, reinforcing the cows vs pigs dynamic
It’s not a “omg this sucks” type of situation, for sure, and I can understand others preferring the new style, I just found the original had a bit more of its own character. Swinky always has been, and still remains, quite the cutie