we have absolutely no idea :D
in all seriously all we can do is speculate right now. maybe the consequence is Lady Tess gets kidnapped and turned into a shifter and we are leaked. or nothing happens and the real consequence is if we don't share ourselves, until it's added we have no idea if it'll happen yet. so just choose what you feel is right, and if it's bad. reload, only one person prevents us from changing out choices and that ONLY includes him lol