Greetings! I started a new game to unlock all revenge animations, but I found that I can only pick one option for the first girl in the forest and somehow managed to lose the revenge with her dog option, maybe because I completed the other quest before that one. Can you probably fix this because the other two seem to be working fine.
Loosing the dog quest is something that was supposed to happen in the versions before this one. But since you started anew... Maybe you need to scroll in the quest log to find it? Once you have finished one path with Annabelle in the forest, just find her again in the same spot in the forest and you will get the other quest.
The order when to finish which quest is not important.