The gray made it difficult to upload new artwork for projects, so I decided to pay the piper.
If this is their way of asking, I don't mind sharing revenue. In fact, I don't even think I knew I had it set to 0% -- I figured I was paying a cut, but I guess that was just taxes, VATs, etc.
More transparency would've been nice, but I don't mind reimbursing them for the ability to use their site. Bandcamp has been doing it on autopilot for years now and pretty much nobody complains about it, because it's just the cost of being part of a wonderful community.
Anyway, I'm still grateful for Itch, even with weird hiccups like this. I understand their need to create pressure surrounding the issue, but a little more transparency and care might've won more people over.