Love this game! I've played it through quite a few times, got each guy to stay and the ending where you can skip to the end, but I can't seem to get them both to stay at the end, no matter how nice I am to them both. Any idea where I might be going wrong?
I'm glad you enjoyed the game!
Getting the ending with both guys requires you to have exactly equal affection for both of them... the skip just makes it easier because there's fewer decisions
Just alternate choices between ones that Ajax and Cato would like.