This is a good one. Well, the introduction is slightly wonky (from what I gather, all citizens aside from the witch entered the dangerous dungeon. Is it a village of mad men?). But once you enter the cave, it's much better. The factions are interesting and described quickly, making it easy to figure out their actions without having to make your way through pages of text. There is a ton of treasure (a dead guy in the first room has a 50 gp idol) but at least it's cursed. Yes, the premise is pretty much "Pirates of the Carribean" but it was a great movie and it works here as well.

The traps make sense and are more than just damage dealers. There is a pirate ship on an underground lake like in the "Goonies". Good stuff. This one goes to my "Adventures" folder, waiting to be played.