We liked the mechanic of searching for items and combining them. Had trouble with the water but was satisfying once completed. Must have taken time making that big map!

Also...nice poop joke.

Congrats on your first game! I got stuck at finding the gunpowder and water, but everything was smooth sailing after that. The puzzles and overall progression were really tight. And I LOLed at more than a few of the plot points and easter eggs hidden throughout the island. Good job man!