I love it, it's so cute! <3

I hope you do realise that being a "goth" in a fashion sense (as I can assume from your comment) has little to nothing to do with gothic literature or, in this case, gothic games. "Gothic" refers to a time period and certain themes, like supernatural, gloomy, mysterious, which is very much what this game is about. So please at least educate yourself before criticising
SPOILER
I've only had one playthrough, and I know you commented 3 years ago lol but maybe it'll help? Aside from being nice and tending to everyone, when Captain asks about your opinion in making plans for the treasure chest (or wtv it was called lol) you have an idea to give the sleeping draught to the enemies. Follow the rest of the story, agree to keep being a doctor at Omen, follow him into his room, drink some wine, cover his hand with yours and kiss!