A big thank you to boyproblems for making this game! I Gmed it over the course of four weeks for four players from my usual playgroup, and we loved it. I was concerned the game would be too somber to really be fun, but it wasn’t that way at all. The mutations were awesome (I’d recommend giving them out earlier than Night 5), and we had a lot of fun trying to make one another laugh by casually slipping in CRJ lyrics (“Just wondering, are we going to try to do this during the day, or at night when everyone’s sleeping, sleeping?”).
It does take a lot of prep to fill out the story and make it work for your group’s needs, but I wrote up a longer post for anyone looking for ideas for something to play this Halloween/spooky October. :) https://docs.google.com/document/d/1piajspDtRlgzCBfjAy_QxuGAT3DICWhxNDh0L2I871M/...