Recipes, if you don't want to discover them by yourself.
| Guest | 1 | 2 | 3 | Result |
| Kogasa | Potion | Mushrooms | Eggs | Tower of Terror Cake |
| Tsukasa | Potion | Spiders | Petals | Bad Apple |
| Rinnosuke | Potion | Mushroms | Sugar | Candy Mushrooms |
| Flandre | Meat | Blood | Spiders | Super Bloody Mary |
| Tenshi | Petals | Sugar | Spiders | Tree Sap Lollipop |
| Nitori | Potion | Mushrooms | Spiders/Blood | Weird-Smelling Juice |
| Suika & Yuugi | Sugar | Eggs | Blood | Oni Macarons |
| Komeiji Sisters | Sugar | Eggs | Petals | Rose Petal Cupcakes |
| Ringo | Spiders | Eggs | Blood | Blood Moon Dango |
| Sakuya | Potion | Spiders | Sugar | Spider Extract Tea |
| Yuuka | Potion | Petals | Sugar | Sunny Lie |
| Mayumi | Blood | Sugar | Meat | Military Rations |