I received an ARC of Cinder last week and have barely put it down since. Thank you, DN Bryn, for your emails pulling me into the GriMM Tales ARC team and for the copy of Cinder.
After the death of his birth mother, Cinder-Szule Reinholz is the only member of the household who knows how to make a home. He does the cooking, the cleaning, the laundry, the shopping, and the mending. His father is constantly away on mysterious business (Cin literally never finds out what his father does, only knowing he comes home with cash), and his stepmother dreams of grandeur with each balance of the checkbook. Cin’s eldest sibling Floy is consumed by their academic studies while his brother Manfred would burn the beans on purpose to avoid doing it again. Cin’s solace are his pet pigeons and his sister Emma (who could be taught chores if he found the time). Well, pigeons, Emma, and his serial killing.
Yeah, there’s a lot going on in this book. In addition to the “Cinderella” plot beats, GriMM Tales tie-ins, and world-building the Hallin kingdom, we have a serial killer plot, a trans medical transition story, an aromantic coming-of-age, and a set up for the next book, The Frog Prince. While Bryn juggles all these elements well enough, the narrative strained under the weight. Some scenes discombobulated, and some questions were unanswered (mostly about the serial killing). Still, from page one Bryn established themself as a fantastic storyteller doing their best to meet the prompt challenge of a GriMM Tale. I buckled in for the ride. The intimate scenes pushed my buttons. I adored the theme work about complex villains and imperfect victims. Bryn engages with, responds to, and critiques the Jack Zipes/Brothers Grimm story. The exact workings of Hallin’s legal system may be murky (do they have divorce? Female inheritance?), but the sensory details made me feel like I could step into it. The pigeons are a delight.
I’ve enjoyed all the GriMM Tales, but Cinder is a highlight. If you’re pursuing queer “Cinderella” retellings, fly away with Cinder!